Rosé's 'APT.' Live Performance Sparks Vocal Debate After Viral Video Hits 3.4 Million Views

Evaluations from international netizens are sharply divided over the live performance of "APT." by BLACKPINK's Rosé in the United States. While some unleashed blunt criticisms targeting her vocal abilities, claiming it "sounds like a middle school talent show," others defended Rosé by pointing to issues with the arrangement and sound. The star of the global hit has found herself embroiled in an unexpected vocal debate following a single stage performance.

On the 8th (Korean time), the U.S. entertainment media outlet The Hollywood Reporter released a video on its official X (formerly Twitter) account showing Rosé performing "APT." at the 2026 Art+Film Gala held at the Los Angeles County Museum of Art (LACMA) on the 7th (local time). As of the 11th, the post has surpassed 3.4 million views. The explosive interest in the short performance video has led to a rapid spread of varying evaluations of the stage.

Following the release of the video, some international netizens directly criticized Rosé's live singing. One netizen offered harsh criticism, stating, "Terrible. It sounds like a middle school talent show," while another wrote, "Her voice is too ordinary. I wonder how she became this famous." Beyond simple differences in taste, reactions emerged that questioned the vocal capabilities of a singer who has achieved worldwide popularity.

Criticism also focused on her vocalization and stage presence. Comments included, "The vocals are a mess in this performance," and "She is out of breath too quickly," while others responded, "It's embarrassing. She has no stage presence to engage the audience at all." The debate grew more intense as some comments sarcastically targeted her reputation as having the best vocal skills among the BLACKPINK members.

The Indian media outlet IndiaTimes also separately reported on the online criticism surrounding Rosé's performance on the 8th. As the global star's stage spread rapidly through overseas media and social media, the evaluation has moved beyond her domestic fandom to an international arena.

However, the reaction was not entirely negative. Arguments were raised in defense of the singer, suggesting that the issues lay with the arrangement and the acoustic environment rather than Rosé's singing. One netizen pointed out, "This song is not a song to be played with just a guitar. If certain instruments are missing, the feeling changes significantly." This interpretation suggests that the charm of the song was diminished because the characteristic rhythm and sound of the original were not sufficiently realized in the live arrangement.

Claims regarding sound issues also continued. Another netizen argued, "The voice is heard far too loudly compared to the instruments. The sound engineer needs to readjust." This suggests that the balance between the vocals and the accompaniment was broken, making the performance appear less polished. Ultimately, this controversy has placed not only Rosé's individual vocal ability but also the appropriateness of the performance environment and arrangement under scrutiny.

Interestingly, U.S. music media outlets gave positive evaluations to other performances Rosé gave at the same event. Regarding her performance of "Read My Mind" by the rock band The Killers on the 9th, Billboard evaluated that "her live voice sounded more powerful than ever and she captured the emotion of the song well." This is a markedly different reaction from the criticism surrounding the "APT." stage.

The music media outlet Stereogum also praised Rosé on the 10th for handling the song well. They also viewed her choice of the hit "Read My Mind" over The Killers' representative song "Mr. Brightside" in a positive light. The fact that evaluations varied depending on the songs performed at the same concert allows for the interpretation that this debate cannot be explained solely by the singer's vocal capabilities.

Rosé performed a total of four songs that day, including "APT.", "Number One Girl", "New Trick", and "Read My Mind". In particular, "New Trick" drew attention as it was the first time the song was revealed as a live performance through this event.

For Rosé, who has proven her presence in the global music market with the worldwide hit "APT.", this stage became an unexpected testing ground for evaluation. With interest concentrated enough for a single live video of one song to record over 3.4 million views, the online debate between harsh criticism and defense is expected to continue for some time. However, as positive reviews for other songs from the same stage were also issued, some point out that it is difficult to judge Rosé's overall vocal capability based on a single performance.

Read the original (Korean)